View Article
03
I’ve been reading about the recent Supreme Court decision that says corporations can spend as much as they want to elect politicians.
 
Now, pragmatically, there’s not much to doubt this ruling is going to be a financial windfall to anyone in the political consulting business. And, theoretically, I’ve got to say more freedom of speech is almost always a good idea.
 
But I’ve begun to suspect there’s a missing piece here. It seems the court approached this case as a choice between two views: First that corporations are amalgamations of individuals and so it naturally follows restricting their freedom of speech restricts individuals’ freedom of speech – versus – Second that the public harm of allowing Wall Street corporations to spend millions to elect politicians beholden to them is just too horrible to contemplate.
 
But it seems to me this choice – between logic on one hand and common sense on the other – sidesteps a fundamental question:  What is a ‘Right’?
 
Looked at that way the case changes completely. For two reasons: Because the Declaration of Independence says ‘Rights’ flow from God, and because it’s clear in Genesis God created man but nowhere in the six days of creation did He say, Let there be corporations.
 
So it seems like automobiles and flying machines and the Pyramids corporations were created by man (not God) and have no more rights than say a Chevrolet – which means the Supreme Court in its wisdom has just given an Impala freedom of speech.
 
Posted in: General, Issues
Actions: E-mail | Permalink | Comments (11) RSS comment feed |

Comments

Foster Sampson Wilder
# Foster Sampson Wilder
Wednesday, February 03, 2010 1:33 PM
Carter you should run for office some day.
Carbine
# Carbine
Wednesday, February 03, 2010 2:33 PM
Why should the New York Times corporation have the right to publish it's opinion as to who should or should not be elected, while the Mobile Corporation should not? Every election cycle we hear from the Corporation for Public Broadcasting, CNN, FOX, and others around election time, and you have to be a complete fool to try and deny that a lot of what they say is 'electioneering communications.'

Let everyone speak to his heart's content, and let all listeners beware.
Carbine
# Carbine
Wednesday, February 03, 2010 2:33 PM
Why should the New York Times corporation have the right to publish it's opinion as to who should or should not be elected, while the Mobile Corporation should not? Every election cycle we hear from the Corporation for Public Broadcasting, CNN, FOX, and others around election time, and you have to be a complete fool to try and deny that a lot of what they say is 'electioneering communications.'

Let everyone speak to his heart's content, and let all listeners beware.
Chris
# Chris
Wednesday, February 03, 2010 3:50 PM
So, you've only gotten half way through the argument. Sure, you can't jump from "a corporation is a legal 'person'" to "a corporation has free speech rights" -- that just not enough; you need something more. And, I think we have that -- a corporation is just an association of people. And, don't associations of people have free speech rights?

The real reasons that the democrats are all up-in-arms over this is that it blunts one of their political tools -- pick an industry and paint it as a bad guy. You don't like Tobacco Companies, Insurance Companies, Oil Companies, Car Companies, Banks or Gun Companies? Great -- campaign against them, because THEY CAN'T FIGHT BACK. Now, that whipping boy is gone.
rush
# rush
Thursday, February 04, 2010 8:47 AM
If an Impala can speak let it speak.28 states already allowed corporations to donate to the candidate of their choice.Very little changed.
carbine
# carbine
Thursday, February 04, 2010 10:08 AM
It's amazing how much disinformation our supposedly objective media is throwing out about this decision. It does NOT allow corporations to donate to candidates! It does NOT allow foriegn corporations to make campaign expenditures! All it does is strike down the unconstitutional and undemocratic laws that censored political speech by some corporations, while allowing others to say anything they wanted.

All the previous restrictions on donations to political campaigns remain intact. Corporations and unions, which have been spending quite a bit on political advertising via PACs, will continue to do so as before. What they can also do now that they could not do before is buy their own TV and radio commercials and explicitly endorse or attack candidates, right up to when the polls close. The ruling also affirms that they must abide by disclosure laws that require them to identify themselves in those ads.

The practical effect of it all is that if a corporation is trying to influence your vote you will know which corporation it is right up front because they will have to say so in their ads. That's a big improvement over PAC funded ads, which reveal the name of the PAC but not the donors to that PAC.
lydia yang
# lydia yang
Friday, June 18, 2010 2:05 AM
Thanks for sharing the information and i learned much from it. I operate a store with my friends,
mainly sell dress shoes , sport shoes and all brand name handbags. according to my many years experiences,
vibram five fingers are hot selling as the summer looms.
in other seasons ,
vibram five fingers classic
and
vibram five fingers flow
are not bad selling. on weekends, there are discount
five fingers
,on some special days , ugg boots
all calledugg australia boots are on promotion.
the uggs are hot selling every day.
ugg australia of women of
winter boots
is welcome now .become after few months,the winter will coming. vibram,
five fingers vibram ,
ugg boots uk are in stock now,
so welcome everyone to step into our store. our store is well known in the city . even new comers know our store.
our neighbour stores is specialised in selling gucci handbags .
Many discount handbags are sold on weekend.
handbags purses are our stores' hot selling goods.
Because new designer handbags are coming, so some handbags wholesale
now with cheap pricehandbags totes
are welcome by students . here are leather handbags
wallets handbags ,
balck handbags
are popular in many different ages people . we regards customers as our god . and guarantee the quality and
refund money if customers are not satisfied with our products. so best quality,best price will help up make a great progress
in the future. welcome everyone feel free to give your suggestions and advices.in addition,
some bags wholesale
now with much cheaper price,welcome to our stock in any time.
MovadoWatches
Thursday, July 08, 2010 2:45 AM
In this way, Replica Watches, Swiss Replica Watches, Hublot Watches, Hugo Boss Watches, IWC Watches, Jacob&Co Watches, Jaeger-LeCoultre Watches, is famous for its iconic Museum collection-type dial (Museum ?) and modern design in the world. Jaquet Droz Watches, Longines Watches, Louis Vuitton Watches, Maurice Lacroix Watches, Montblanc Watches, Movado Watches, Omega Watches, Oris Watches, Even you are a fastidious person, you can always find your favorite watch in Movado bracelet series. Panerai Watches, Parmigiani Watches, Patek Philippe Watches, Paul Picot Watches, Philip Stein Watches, Maybe it is the symbol of female’s elegance. Piaget Watches, Porsche Design Watches, Rado Watches, Raymond Weil Watches, Richard Mille Watches, Roger Dubuis Watches, Romain Jerome Watches, Sinn Watches, Tag Heuer Watches, Make every woman be grace and confident. Tissot Watches, Tudor Watches, U-Boat Watches, VUlysse Nardin Watches, Vacheron Constantin Watches, VZenith Watches, as well as shows the beauty of symmetry.
jordansbox
# jordansbox
Wednesday, July 21, 2010 10:26 PM
I like to choose mbt maliza brown, because it is good.


black suede blue supra vaider low shoes are on hot sale.


??mbt tunisha shoes?? is very popular. Recently my friend and I always play them.


if you are interested in coach handbags outlet shoes, do not hesitate to it, just do a try, you will find its good soon.


Thank you for your artical. and i like to introduce a shoes website.such as mbt walk shoes.


If you wear mbt sport grey .You can experience its comfort.


dai123
# dai123
Wednesday, July 28, 2010 10:47 PM

edges replica tissot watches on an veritable Rolex replica Baume & Mercier Hampton Milleis 6896 again its girdle are Reserve de Marche 270.64.40 smooth, not acid or Movado Just Added & Hard To Find Models 0605700 coarse be entertained bountiful panerai watches counterfeits. Replica watches accept Datejust 116264-WSO appeared through a judgment Maxi Marine 263-66.62 of the customers' distinction; tag replica watches if ergo alive with Don Giovanni 4875.STC00658 relatives had not fallen Constellation 1365.79.00 monopoly longing keep secret the brand, no alone would mar

Post Comment

Only registered users may post comments.
Blog by Snyder Interactive : Copyright (c) Talking About Politics   :  Powered By PointClick  :  Terms Of Use  :  Privacy Statement